Well... it's finally time for the big reveal for our "new" dining room. Thanks for giving me
feedback about wainscoting for our home. The process was quite a lot of work for hubby and I, but I think the results are really worth it. I'm going to post the photos of the finished product first, and then I'll go into more detail below.
Cliff's Notes Version:
Before:

After:
And, now if you are interested or bored, the backstory...
At the beginning of September, I
mentioned that I had wainscoting on the mind. You all recommended that we go with board and batten. (And, some of you were even kind enough to give me links to more information.)
Once I figured out what board and batten was, I knew I needed it in our dining room. It was life or death, people. Life.or.death.
Poor husband. He didn't stand a chance.
Unfortunately, something I didn't mention in the first post was that Ryan was adamantly AGAINST any type of wainscoting. (Bad wife. Bad, bad wife.) So, following the aforementioned blog post, when I decided that board and batten was a must, Ryan and I talked about it.
(When I say we talked about it, what I actually mean is that I begged and Ryan declined. And, then we both went back to our corners. After thinking about it, I actually decided that Ryan was right about wainscoting (but don't tell him). It would be a lot of work. Our house is about the farthest thing from level that a home can get. And, our house really is lovely as is. He's done a lot of work already. I was beginning to feel bad about begging for it.)
So, I didn't bring it up for, I don't know, an hour. Maybe two? ;)
But seriously, we both just kinda dropped it for a few weeks.
Then, on a Thursday night that will forever live in infamy, we were talking about the weekend. I asked what his plans were. He said...
"Well, I was thinking I could put up wainscoting for you in the dining room."
SCREECH..... My heart stopped. Then, I screamed. Then, I thanked him. Then, I cried. Then, I had to go hang out with Google for an hour (or four) to find out what exactly we needed to get at the hardware store the next day.
Thus began our progress with wainscoting.
We thought it would be simple. Hehe... hoho.... haha. The truth is, everyone does it a little different. Everyone's home is different. So, we used a few tutorials online and then kinda trusted our guts to finish it. It worked out pretty great in the end.
The process
Our home has textured walls. I tell you up front this because it means that the faux-paneling methods that are gracing the Internet really wouldn't work for us. Most tutorials that I found just put the boards right over the existing walls. We couldn't do this with textured walls because if we just put the boards up over the wall, it would look silly. It wouldn't look like board-and-batten. It would look like boards over textured walls.
So, we decided to use a base of plywood. It's really just an extra step.
The supply list in the words of Kim:
- (base) 48 feet of 1/4 inch birch plywood
- (vertical boards) 35 - 3/8 inch deep clear pine boards, (36 inches tall, 3/8 inch thick, 3 inches wide)
- (top horizontal boards) 48 feet - 1x4 clear pine boards, (3/4 inch thick, 4 inches wide)
- lots of paintable white caulk
- nail gun with 2 inch and 1 1/2 inch nails
- semi-gloss trim paint
- foam roller
- touch-up paint
Here's a diagram of the sizes of boards we used, for visual reference.
The process:
Begin with the plywood as a base. Ryan began from the corners and worked his way around the room.
Ryan measured each area to cut around electrical outlets, windows and corner decorative moldings. This took a great deal of time, because our home is very old and very uneven.
Measure a lot. Measure more. Measure one last time.
When the boards were cut (they are 36 inches high), he nailed them to the wall with a nail gun. I thought we should use some sort of glue, but I was wrong. The nails hold up plenty well.

The corners do not have to be perfect (even if your wife is worried that they should be). Any gaps can very easily be concealed with caulk.
You'll also notice that the boards ended up being a little different in height. It's the bane of poor Ryan's existence. Our house is that far from being level. In some places, it was a difference of an inch. He concealed the difference later with the top board.
Here's what it was looking like after a few boards were up.

Notice the pretty little corner decorative pieces. How did he cut around these?

He made a template.

I suggested Ryan cut the boards inside. It was nasty outside and I didn't want the boards to get wet. Very bad idea. Very very bad idea. I don't know what got into me. Luckily, the rain cleared up and the saw went back outside.
Keep measuring.... you are doing good.



Next, Ryan put the horizontal boards on the walls. We wanted it level, regardless of whether the floor is level (which it isn't). I didn't get any pictures of this process.
But, essentially - we did a little math to figure out that the biggest discrepancy was about an inch at the top. So, we cut a chunk out of the back of the board so that it would slide up to an inch down, over the 1/4 inch plywood. It looked similar to the way hardwood floors snap together. Then, we just used a level to put up the boards around the room. They are all level. YAY!
Following the horizontal board, Ryan cut the vertical boards and installed them 18 inches apart from each other.

Note: Everyone seems to do this a little differently (see links below). We decided that we wanted the boards equally spaced on all walls. Some people center each wall and make the boards differing distances. Some start on the edges.

I don't really think it makes a big difference. Just personal preference. I like the way ours turned out, and I know that they are all equally-spaced. That's good for a type-A person like me.

This entire process took about one day. Then, Ryan caulked all the gaps, the nail holes and in between boards.
Next, I painted the wainscoting.
It took one coat of oil-based primer and three coats of white, semi-gloss paint. At that point the coverage was good.
Here are some close-ups. Even though the baseboards are almost 100 years older than the rest, I think it blends pretty well. (I touched up the baseboards, too. It's scary how much they needed it.)
Then, we just put our room back together. And cleaned. A lot.
Ryan and I like to tell each other that we feel like millionaires now. The woodwork is that good.
So... if you've made it this long... I'm shocked. And impressed. But, mostly shocked. If we really were millionaires, we'd send you a million dollars. But we aren't. Sorry, friends. Maybe someday.
Hope the tutorial was helpful and interesting for you. And, I hope you like what we've done. Ryan and I are surely happy with the result.
(Actually, I'm the happy one. Ryan told me that he likes it. But, really he's just happy that I'm happy. He kinda rules.)
Appendix:
In case you are also interested in Board and Batten, here are a few links that I came across while planning. I hope they are helpful.
There are probably millions more.... hang out with my bff,
Google. He'll help a brotha' (or sista') out.
Read more...